Science Shepherd vs Bob Jones Life Science

Middle School Life Science Comparison

We continue our series of science curriculum comparisons today by looking at middle school Life Science for homeschool from Science Shepherd and BJU Press Homeschool. Rather than being a detailed review, this is a comparison to highlight some of the similarities and differences between the two programs to help homeschool families decide which would be the best fit for them. Our goal in providing this is to help you get the most appropriate course for your student. If it is Science Shepherd, that’s great! If it isn’t, that’s great, too! The key is bringing you information that is as objective as possible so you can make a good decision for you and your family.

Last month, we compared Science Shepherd Biology and Apologia Exploring Creation with Biology.
You can read that comparison here.

Textbook

Summary: The Life Science textbooks from Science Shepherd and BJU Press Homeschool are similar in scope and recognize God’s Word as absolute truth and the lens through which science is properly understood. Clearly, there is a difference regarding how their similar scopes handle topics, organize information content, etc., considering the BJU text is heftier than Science Shepherd. Science Shepherd's Life Science text is straightforward, presenting scientific concepts in a step-wise fashion, without introducing worldview/philosophical discussion into the science presentation and avoiding sidebar topics so the students focus on the scientific concepts. Creation and evolution are discussed in depth after the student spends about half the year learning the science upon which the creation and evolution discussion is based. At all points, step-wise knowledge acquisition and integration processes are emphasized so the student learns HOW to learn, not just what to learn, developing critical thinking skills in the process. BJU Press takes a more “standardized textbook approach” and includes discussions and dedicated sections - Case Studies and Ethics - to cover critical thinking, creation and evolution, and other concepts. On the topic of origins, both texts include a chapter on creation and evolution; it is confined to that chapter in Science Shepherd’s text but is visited throughout BJU Press’ text. For review, Science Shepherd provides review questions at the end of each chapter, while BJU provides review questions followng major chapter sections, and at the end of each chapter. Also, both Science Shepherd and BJU Press Homeschool offer their Life Science textbooks in an interactive eBook format. Science Shepherd provides 15 months of access to the eBook, while BJU Press Homeschool offers 16 months.

Answer Key & Parent Companion / Teacher's Edition and Answer Key

Summary: Science Shepherd and BJU Press Homeschool have taken drastically different approaches to their parent material. The Science Shepherd Life Science Answer Key & Parent Companion is a condensed, section-by-section review of the textbook, highlighting key concepts, with additional study questions parents can ask to help ensure their student(s) understand and can critically think about the material. The Science Shepherd Answer Key & Parent Companion also includes all chapter review and test question answers. The BJU Press Life Science Teacher’s Edition is a complete copy of their student textbook with additional parent information and review questions added, and other additional resources for parents and students. Assessment answers for BJU Press’s Life Science are provided in a separate book. Both parent resources provide a recommended syllabus.

Test Booklet

Summary: No major difference here. The tests for Science Shepherd Life Science occur every few chapters, while those for BJU Press Homeschool Life Science occur every chapter. Science Shepherd testing uses the same formatting as the end of chapter questions, and none of the test questions are repeats of the chapter questions.

That summarizes the core material for middle school Life Science from Science Shepherd and BJU Press Homeschool. Both publishers do offer a bundle of the course; Science Shepherd's Life Science 3-Book Set for $71.25, and BJU Press Homeschool’s Life Science Subject Kit for $225.40. The BJU kit also includes their student and teacher lab manuals, which we will discuss next.

Lab Manual

Summary: Science Shepherd and BJU Press Homeschool have made lab resources available for their Life Science classes, but the two differ substantially. Science Shepherd Life Science utilizes the Life Science Quest for Middle Grades activity book as the recommended lab material for their class. This book includes labs and other activities, which are performed in conjunction with the Life Science textbook readings, and one of the major goals of this lab experience is to keep it simple but effective, using materials that most houses/kitchens have on stock, or are very cheap to purchase. A parent’s guide is provided in the back of the activity book. BJU Press’ Life Science Lab Manual includes chapter review worksheets, as well as labs and other activities such as research assignments and field studies. BJU Press Homeschool provides a separate answer key. Similar to the Teacher’s Edition textbook, the Activities Answer Key from BJU Press includes the full lab manual, with lab guides, answers, and additional resources added in.

Video Course

Science Shepherd and BJU Homeschool Press both have optional video courses available for their Life Science curriculum. The following is a brief review of those resources.

We hope this has been a helpful (and fair) overview to you of the homeschool Life Science curriculum available from Science Shepherd and BJU Press Homeschool! If you have any questions about our middle school material, please send us a message through our contact page, and we would be happy to help.

Note: Information and pricing accurate, as much as it has been understood, as of May 31, 2019. Revised June 27, 2025.

Until Next Time!
Science Shepherd